• Staff Applications are OPEN! [ Staff / Moderator ] More Info HERE Help us make a better forum for everyone!

[Melissa N.] Collection

Aphrodite Mirror is not a bad comic, but it is too complicated, and there is also a reason why ? Why people unable to understand the plots and who is the main mastermind!
Melissa once mentioned that , she inspired FROM Auther Conan Doyle ( who created sharlock Holmes) , like his story until the very end no one able to understand who is the real culprit, and what is motive behind it , the culprit Wil be INFORNT of everyone, but no one have any slitest dought on culprit, that is sharlock Holmes work, we all know that ,

So she inspired FROM sir Conan Doyle, and creates Aphrodite Mirror, that is why until know no one fully understand the story atleast what will happen next no one able to guse it , and for that I would like to say , Melissa did a terrific job .

You have to wait till the end for fully understand
 
Aphrodite Mirror is not a bad comic, but it is too complicated, and there is also a reason why ? Why people unable to understand the plots and who is the main mastermind!
Melissa once mentioned that , she inspired FROM Auther Conan Doyle ( who created sharlock Holmes) , like his story until the very end no one able to understand who is the real culprit, and what is motive behind it , the culprit Wil be INFORNT of everyone, but no one have any slitest dought on culprit, that is sharlock Holmes work, we all know that ,

So she inspired FROM sir Conan Doyle, and creates Aphrodite Mirror, that is why until know no one fully understand the story atleast what will happen next no one able to guse it , and for that I would like to say , Melissa did a terrific job .

You have to wait till the end for fully understand
I think the butler did it...haha. I like the story but am beginning to appreciate why some people wait till a comic is completed before reading. I follow a similar approach on Netflix waiting for the full season of a show to wrap up before watching. In my mind, Mr. Seferi, Eva, Sophia and Marina are the closest to being culprits. Marina's mother may have a grudge against Nikos, Eva and Sophia may have a grudge against their dad for being a womanizer and not sure about Seferi but maybe he was intimately related to Nikos back in time before he went to prison. The key question is how does the former Andrew now Elena fit in and what will become of Joel now perhaps Jolene? :)
 
Aphrodite Mirror is not a bad comic, but it is too complicated, and there is also a reason why ? Why people unable to understand the plots and who is the main mastermind!
Melissa once mentioned that , she inspired FROM Auther Conan Doyle ( who created sharlock Holmes) , like his story until the very end no one able to understand who is the real culprit, and what is motive behind it , the culprit Wil be INFORNT of everyone, but no one have any slitest dought on culprit, that is sharlock Holmes work, we all know that ,

So she inspired FROM sir Conan Doyle, and creates Aphrodite Mirror, that is why until know no one fully understand the story atleast what will happen next no one able to guse it , and for that I would like to say , Melissa did a terrific job .

You have to wait till the end for fully understand
I don't want to argue, I really respect your opinion and I've read lots of your comments and totally agree but I have to strongly disagree with this one

I don't think it's a good story, I've read Sherlock Holmes and other mystery novels and this one might be trying to do something similar but in my opinion it's failing
The story is just not good enough, there are many things that really make no sense and I think that it might be because she's trying to do 2 things at once
She keeps trying to please her usual public, that most of them don't really care about the depth of the story or if it can be realistic or not, they just want a man turning into a woman and seeing lots of sexy or even sex scenes
And at the same time she's trying to create something with more depth but the plot is just not string enough, the characters are not real enough and lots of the decisions they make are plain dumb and make no sense,for example we see Elena after having anal sex remembering she's really a man and thinking she wants to go back to his real life so he goes to talkl to Marina and because she gets angry because she finds out he had sex with a man then Elena decides she will now really have sex with a man. He no longer wants to go back to being a man or try to fix things with his wife, just out of nowhere he changes his mind and the whole idea of him being conflicted and trying to return things is just ignored so we can have lots of pages of sex....

Again it's just my opinion and many people might disagree but for me the story is just bad and dumb
 
I don't want to argue, I really respect your opinion and I've read lots of your comments and totally agree but I have to strongly disagree with this one

I don't think it's a good story, I've read Sherlock Holmes and other mystery novels and this one might be trying to do something similar but in my opinion it's failing
The story is just not good enough, there are many things that really make no sense and I think that it might be because she's trying to do 2 things at once
She keeps trying to please her usual public, that most of them don't really care about the depth of the story or if it can be realistic or not, they just want a man turning into a woman and seeing lots of sexy or even sex scenes
And at the same time she's trying to create something with more depth but the plot is just not string enough, the characters are not real enough and lots of the decisions they make are plain dumb and make no sense,for example we see Elena after having anal sex remembering she's really a man and thinking she wants to go back to his real life so he goes to talkl to Marina and because she gets angry because she finds out he had sex with a man then Elena decides she will now really have sex with a man. He no longer wants to go back to being a man or try to fix things with his wife, just out of nowhere he changes his mind and the whole idea of him being conflicted and trying to return things is just ignored so we can have lots of pages of sex....

Again it's just my opinion and many people might disagree but for me the story is just bad and dumb
I totally agree with you, what you mentioned is truth. But what I said is she was inspired by sir Conan Doyle! Then write AM. Now , is this even possible to write similar story like Conan Doyle sir , in history many writers try to copy his style, there could not even near his work!

As for Melissa, well I guess she wants to create suspence! And she created it ! Whether it has lots of hole and no logic many times, but she successfully created suspense story! That is why I said AM is good !
For suspence point of view.
And for my personal opinion I stopped it at chapters 15 ! I couldn't take the Merinas cheating and I don't like the idia, she is a BITCH,
 
A Sweet Change 7

SECRETARY97.png SECRETARY98.png SECRETARY99.png SECRETARY100.png SECRETARY101.png SECRETARY102.png SECRETARY103.png SECRETARY104.png SECRETARY105.png SECRETARY106.png SECRETARY107.png SECRETARY108.png SECRETARY109.png
 
I don't want to argue, I really respect your opinion and I've read lots of your comments and totally agree but I have to strongly disagree with this one

I don't think it's a good story, I've read Sherlock Holmes and other mystery novels and this one might be trying to do something similar but in my opinion it's failing
The story is just not good enough, there are many things that really make no sense and I think that it might be because she's trying to do 2 things at once
She keeps trying to please her usual public, that most of them don't really care about the depth of the story or if it can be realistic or not, they just want a man turning into a woman and seeing lots of sexy or even sex scenes
And at the same time she's trying to create something with more depth but the plot is just not string enough, the characters are not real enough and lots of the decisions they make are plain dumb and make no sense,for example we see Elena after having anal sex remembering she's really a man and thinking she wants to go back to his real life so he goes to talkl to Marina and because she gets angry because she finds out he had sex with a man then Elena decides she will now really have sex with a man. He no longer wants to go back to being a man or try to fix things with his wife, just out of nowhere he changes his mind and the whole idea of him being conflicted and trying to return things is just ignored so we can have lots of pages of sex....

Again it's just my opinion and many people might disagree but for me the story is just bad and dumb
The thing is that detective is a very special genre. And those who are good at it rarely succeed in other genres. At the same time, masters of other genres can rarely write a solid detective.

For example, I would not dare to take on a real detective, leaving myself only elements. Because I understand how specific this genre is, requiring just a special way of thinking and approach.

The key feature of the genre is that the story must be thought out in one piece, completely with all the details. And therefore detectives traditionally come out as short stories.
 
The thing is that detective is a very special genre. And those who are good at it rarely succeed in other genres. At the same time, masters of other genres can rarely write a solid detective.

For example, I would not dare to take on a real detective, leaving myself only elements. Because I understand how specific this genre is, requiring just a special way of thinking and approach.

The key feature of the genre is that the story must be thought out in one piece, completely with all the details. And therefore detectives traditionally come out as short stories.
And Sir Conan Doyle is one of the all time greatest
 
I like A Sweet Change, didn't Melissa say it was going to be a short story though?

It started off well but the story now seems to be moving at a glacial rate.
 
I think I missed the point. Is it because of the hormones that he started gaining weight?
As per I know about HRT , it is a possible possibility, after taking HRT , when estrogen started action in the body then fat displacement is a very possible effect, where you mussels muss will be reduced and fat getting stored in various body parts like thies, reear, hass and chest and belly! Its GIVES a curvy figure if the constitution and DNA is good enough though!
So , is "Sweet change" it is highly near to real HRT
Well , I am not an expert nor I ever taken HRT treatment so , what I know is besically reading verious articles .
People who really gone through HRT they can explain better, and I am also not saying what i say I is truth! It is just my half baked knowledge
 
I like A Sweet Change, didn't Melissa say it was going to be a short story though?

It started off well but the story now seems to be moving at a glacial rate.
Well , you have to understand who is saying "Short" for Melissa where her another comics is also going to touch 1500 pages, for her point of view,her short would be around 200-250 or 300 pages 😹
 
I don't think there's much left but yes its not short as older ones. Melissa stretches what she did over several pages several times over. While the updates for this story are pretty short. 109 now and how much happened, A (Not So) Temporary Roommate had 163 pages and had much more actions.
 
Back
Top Bottom