[Musclefan] Collection

[Your Favourite Anon]

Hey, sorry to ask, but do you also feel like some of these musclefan comics have become formulaic?

I don't want to defame anyone and claim that these comics are bad, because the truth is that they're quite still good and they were good. It just became more formulaic than it was years ago. There are a lot of sequels to the same story, which are often such a light muscle boost to already muscular female or artist making transformation just so quick. Sometimes in plot something is missing, like a spark.

I guess comics like Swamp Fever, Supplemental, Power Plant or Massive Inheritance would even gain a lot of attention today and record good numbers.
I'm ofc fan of musclefan stories and comics, but it has started to losing my happiness with reading every next comic.

However, I encourage you to buy comics because they are good, there will probably be something for everyone!

Tbh I have to agree, I am personally not a big fan of already muscular character becoming larger. It just doesn't hit the same way as a small character becoming big, yk? I enjoy those stories and would like to see more of them especially new ones and not yet another sequel.

 

[hacaci4880]

Tbh I have to agree, I am personally not a big fan of already muscular character becoming larger. It just doesn't hit the same way as a small character becoming big, yk? I enjoy those stories and would like to see more of them especially new ones and not yet another sequel.

Good to see someone with similar opinion. I really miss old stories as they got more bit spooky vibe and less too much cartoon basic style. Also not fan of sequels...

 

[kono]

Hey, sorry to ask, but do you also feel like some of these musclefan comics have become formulaic?

I don't want to defame anyone and claim that these comics are bad, because the truth is that they're quite still good and they were good. It just became more formulaic than it was years ago. There are a lot of sequels to the same story, which are often such a light muscle boost to already muscular female or artist making transformation just so quick. Sometimes in plot something is missing, like a spark.

I guess comics like Swamp Fever, Supplemental, Power Plant or Massive Inheritance would even gain a lot of attention today and record good numbers.
I'm ofc fan of musclefan stories and comics, but it has started to losing my happiness with reading every next comic.

However, I encourage you to buy comics because they are good, there will probably be something for everyone!

I see your point; honestly, there are some comics I wish had sequels, but I guess they didn't sell well.

 

[adfssfdsfddfs]

I actually kinda hate muscle fan. Like MFMC has a bit of a hyper masochism problem, Amy's conquest guys were way to glued to their stuff that repulsed me (nothing like a 5' chick with bricks for arms overpowering a normal guy with no build up or deeper meaning?), etc.

But all those guys had some skin. I'm trying to think of anything I thought was amazing and I'm drawing a blank, which isn't the case with giantessfan or other sites.

 

[hacaci4880]

I actually kinda hate muscle fan. Like MFMC has a bit of a hyper masochism problem, Amy's conquest guys were way to glued to their stuff that repulsed me (nothing like a 5' chick with bricks for arms overpowering a normal guy with no build up or deeper meaning?), etc.

But all those guys had some skin. I'm trying to think of anything I thought was amazing and I'm drawing a blank, which isn't the case with giantessfan or other sites.

The latest kinda decent comic by musclefan for me was Muscle Foods, released over 9 months ago - reason is maybe more focused on transformation scene than just action after or before. Earlier also good comic was Night of the Living Amazons, released almost 2 years ago. Now most of these are quick muscular sequel stories, containing nothing than just being a hero and saving someone or fighting with other muscular woman.

Also not my types of artists today there are, but whatever.

 

[hacaci4880]

I would love to read a comic (published every 2-3 months) focusing on a detailed body transformation rather than just reading same fighting battle of superheroes. Whether triggered by a lab ray, symbiote or a magical meteorite, the core of the story should be the 3-6 pages of growing, not just from 18 pages, max 2 pages are transformation and rest is about destroying city or growing larger and larger and larger (it's not giantess comic man).

 

[kono]

I would love to read a comic (published every 2-3 months) focusing on a detailed body transformation rather than just reading same fighting battle of superheroes. Whether triggered by a lab ray, symbiote or a magical meteorite, the core of the story should be the 3-6 pages of growing, not just from 18 pages, max 2 pages are transformation and rest is about destroying city or growing larger and larger and larger (it's not giantess comic man).

I’d like it to focus on that too. There are comics I find really bland—they’re just muscular girls doing things. There’s no progression or anything like that.
Do you know Manic's comics? I feel like he focuses more on the growth sequence.

 

[hacaci4880]

I’d like it to focus on that too. There are comics I find really bland—they’re just muscular girls doing things. There’s no progression or anything like that.
Do you know Manic's comics? I feel like he focuses more on the growth sequence.

Manic was carrying entire muscle growth fetish in worst times.

One man saving entire community... Great artist.