-
Staff Applications are OPEN! [ Staff / Moderator ] More Info HERE Help us make a better forum for everyone!
[Scarlett Duffy] Hotwife, Cuckold, Interracial
- Thread starter KidneyCracker
- Start date
- hotwife
- interracial netorare
O_P_T
Active member
All of her stuff is plagiarized.
A Wife Shared - MY WIFE BECCA by Bridgekicker
A Wife Shares - MY WIFE BECCA CH. 03
No Turning Back - My Wife Alexis by Bridgekicker
Big Black Business Trip - MY BEST BUSINESS TRIP YET by BBCXXX
Her Next Black Business Trip - MY BEST BUSINESS TRIP YET CH. 03
You Wanted This - A Cuckold Story by mbtaichi
I suspect it's another variation on the following plagiarizers, many of whom have been taken down from Amazon. Presumably because they were identified as plagiarizers:
Blake Barkley
Gabriel Garnier
Leah Larkin
Leigh Temple
Millie Carter
Scarlett Johnson
With the exception of Gabriel Garnier, they all used a similar cover style, as exemplified with the stories you posted. When I see that, I check to see if I can find the original source using the google search trick you ( at least I think it was you) posted.
Attached is a list I posted at 8Muses that identifies the source of the story that was ripped off for many of the authors above.
A Wife Shared - MY WIFE BECCA by Bridgekicker
A Wife Shares - MY WIFE BECCA CH. 03
No Turning Back - My Wife Alexis by Bridgekicker
Big Black Business Trip - MY BEST BUSINESS TRIP YET by BBCXXX
Her Next Black Business Trip - MY BEST BUSINESS TRIP YET CH. 03
You Wanted This - A Cuckold Story by mbtaichi
I suspect it's another variation on the following plagiarizers, many of whom have been taken down from Amazon. Presumably because they were identified as plagiarizers:
Blake Barkley
Gabriel Garnier
Leah Larkin
Leigh Temple
Millie Carter
Scarlett Johnson
With the exception of Gabriel Garnier, they all used a similar cover style, as exemplified with the stories you posted. When I see that, I check to see if I can find the original source using the google search trick you ( at least I think it was you) posted.
Attached is a list I posted at 8Muses that identifies the source of the story that was ripped off for many of the authors above.
Attachments
KidneyCracker
Active member
figured as much.
FC1(SW) Retired
Active member
I was just looking for some of 'Blake Barkley's books because Goodreads recommended him based on some of my shelves. Now that I know he's a plagiarist, do you know his favorite target so I can get it from the original author?
Also I remember running across that plagiarist thread on 8 muses just before it collapsed. If you have that information, and apparently intimate knowledge of it you could reproduce the known plagiarist thread here as its own thread, and maybe we could petition to get it to be a sticky thread.
KidneyCracker
Active member
look in that pdf that @O_P_T posted. He even has links to pages where you can find the original stories
O_P_T
Active member
Here's the google search I used to find the original author. Just put a text string from the book in suspect in quotes to replace "fantasy"
"fantasy" site:lushstories.com | site:literotica.com | site:asstr.org | site:asstr.xyz | site:darkwanderer.net | site:storiesonline.net | site:swinglifestyle.com | site:blackdemonstories.com | site:4freestories.com | site:allme.com | site:blacktowhite.net | site:sexstories.com | site:reddit.comnt=gws-wiz-serp
Also, avoid character names since the plagiarizers typically do a search and replace. It may take a few tries to get a hit, since some of them do a bit of editing.
BTW, astr.xyz appears to be down and has been for the past few days.
oxa4r5t
Member
i can't find this one in the PDF posted so is this is an original one? Would be kind of you if anyone can provide me this!
Thankyou!
KidneyCracker
Active member
If the rest are stolen then it probably is too. The person must have a source we haven't found or it's from asstr which appears to be gone. Being this flagrant, wouldn't be surprised if was from another author's book.
note, some of asstr can be found here if you don't want to go download the old siterip
note, some of asstr can be found here if you don't want to go download the old siterip
Last edited:
O_P_T
Active member
It appears to be Sam and Edward by steviet
I looked at the sample at Amazon, and it sounded familiar. Took a bit of the combo Google search to get a hit (specialist dive company was the winner)
FC1(SW) Retired
Active member
Could you add Plagarist to the thread's title - since we've pretty much determined she is?
oxa4r5t
Member
Thankyou for that!
O_P_T
Active member
OK, I may have to reassess my opinion on this writer.
Still a plagiarizer, but she doesn't just do a search and replace on the character names anymore. In fact, it's gotten more difficult to use the multiple site google search trick to find the original work she copied, She simply edits the text so much it's hard to find a phrase that is exactly the same in both works.
Here's a good example.
I picked up "The Hotwife: A Husband Watches His Cuckold Fantasy Become Reality" and it is a rework of "Mary and her Lovers" by jawanaut @ literotica.
jawanaut's version is ~3.4k words, and Duffy's is ~7.7k words.
In addition, there is a substantial difference in the appearance of certain key words, that IMHO, track how "hot" a story would be. In the list below jawanaut's version is listed first and Duffy's second.
moan: 13/97
orgasm: 11/37
climax: 3/9
cum: 46/130
scream: 9/14
Now since Duffy's book is a little more than twice the size of jawanaut's, that explains some of the difference, but certainly can't explain moan, orgasm, or cum.
So, the version she makes, just might be "better" than the source material, at least it is substantially changed, as she extends the description of the naughty bits substantially.
Still a plagiarizer, but she doesn't just do a search and replace on the character names anymore. In fact, it's gotten more difficult to use the multiple site google search trick to find the original work she copied, She simply edits the text so much it's hard to find a phrase that is exactly the same in both works.
Here's a good example.
I picked up "The Hotwife: A Husband Watches His Cuckold Fantasy Become Reality" and it is a rework of "Mary and her Lovers" by jawanaut @ literotica.
jawanaut's version is ~3.4k words, and Duffy's is ~7.7k words.
In addition, there is a substantial difference in the appearance of certain key words, that IMHO, track how "hot" a story would be. In the list below jawanaut's version is listed first and Duffy's second.
moan: 13/97
orgasm: 11/37
climax: 3/9
cum: 46/130
scream: 9/14
Now since Duffy's book is a little more than twice the size of jawanaut's, that explains some of the difference, but certainly can't explain moan, orgasm, or cum.
So, the version she makes, just might be "better" than the source material, at least it is substantially changed, as she extends the description of the naughty bits substantially.
FC1(SW) Retired
Active member
A lot of the mass production authors need someone to go and clean-up/improve their work - preferably before they publish.
I've just finished reading some of PhDomme Emma's stories - they are good, but they have such a huge capability to be Great, if she would just edit and proofread.
I wouldn't have an issue with people like Scarlett Duffy if they would at least credit the original author with the initial concept and make it a fan-based improvement, not an outright steal.
FC1(SW) Retired
Active member
In fact reflecting upon this - I don't find it such a bad idea at all. It has several appealing concepts to it:
1. It will get the original artist more attention
2. I will show the original artist how much better their work could be
3. It will give the 'fan based editor' more experience writing and proofing so that maybe they would start to produce their own work
4. It could help someone like me get through the writer's block that has been plaguing me since I lost my muse.
But if I do it I would do it like I suggested - giving full credit to the original author, and I post it for free under a psuedonym, maybe this one.
I'll have to think about it.
yano2mch
Professional Geeky Perv
Sounds interesting. Let me know if we figure this out. I'd probably be halfway decent at this, though i doubt i could make a living on it.
But rewriting or adding more fluff to scenes and fixing minor issues would certainly be worth doing; But some authors would definitely be angry you did a better job than they did.
Hmmm... i'm suddenly reminded of Harry Potter series. I HATE Rowling's
Guess i'm saying some things (aside from authors threatening to sue you) just can't be changed/fixed.
FC1(SW) Retired
Active member
That's why I suggested doing it as fan fiction - there is a long historical precedent that fan fiction is acceptable and not a copyright offense. To site just a few: Edgar Rice Burrough's stuff, Star Trek, Star Wars, Conan, etc..
Especially when the originator is cited, it's not plagiarism to quote works you just have to add to it. But in a stretch, at need, it could be considered parody if you improve it dramatically.
I'd say our Original Erotic Literature Forum might be a good place for it.
But I also think the only way to make legitimate money at it, is if your work is good enough to grab the attention of other writers, and they commission you to proof-read, and co-author edit their work.
Unfortunately for me - I am a dinosaur, and prefer to hardcopy edit - so if I do this I will be forced to evolve, it has been so long since I've used my printer, I doubt it even works anymore.
O_P_T
Active member
I guess I wasn't clear in my recent post.
I'm not forgiving her for plagiarizing the work. Doing so without attribution is not acceptable.
My main point is that the version Duffy et al put out might be a "better" story, that the version they are stealing.
In earlier posts about the various plagiarizing authors, I've posted links to the original material they stole, thinking the two versions were essentially the same.
Considering that it was very easy to do a search on a phrase and find the original, that probably was mostly true.
I've noticed in the past few months, that when I get a story on mobilism from Duffy or Leah Jenkins, it's a bit harder to find the magic phrase that finds the orginal story.
I hadn't really thought about that too much previously, but when I compared the two versions listed above, the changes were substantial, and not simply changing the names of the characters.
So, that's why it's harder to do a search to find the original, because of the major re-write that was done.
Now if as you suggest Duffy et al identified the "inspiration" for the original, that would be much better, and might entice me to actually purchase some of their work. Without them doing so, I will never give them a dime.
I'm not an expert on copywrite law, so I don't know where the line is legally as to how much you'd have to change the work to not infringe on the original author's rights. I suspect that's most of the reason they don't do this.
FC1(SW) Retired
Active member
I'm not sure where the line is either, but the line is definitely crossed when the original author is ignored.
That is THE main reason I haven't played Dungeons and Dragons since 2nd edition came out. There is ZERO reference to E Gary Gygax(Egg) in the 2nd edition Player's Handbook I purchased - and as a tweenager I knew that was wrong.
I met the man at the 1982 World Science Fiction Convention in Chicago - he did not deserve to be thrown out like the garbage when he sold the game he invented.
That is THE main reason I haven't played Dungeons and Dragons since 2nd edition came out. There is ZERO reference to E Gary Gygax(Egg) in the 2nd edition Player's Handbook I purchased - and as a tweenager I knew that was wrong.
I met the man at the 1982 World Science Fiction Convention in Chicago - he did not deserve to be thrown out like the garbage when he sold the game he invented.
O_P_T
Active member
One of the boys is Just One of The Guys by CraptainPlanet
Duffy's comes in at a word count of 61K words, CraptainPlanet's at 64K words.
Headonism is from SwingLifeStyle
Duffy's version is 35K words, the original is 30k words.
Similar threads
