Sire_rickenbach, stories are truly great if you don't know where it's headed or even if you know where it's headed, there better be some gnarly bends in the road.
The four outlines or endings you laid are not very appealing to be honest. The best stories I've read always read like a heist, a pursuit of the incredibly beautiful women, against all odds to the MC. ....
Take note that her output is W-A-Y down. She lost her job, got a new job, various things going on obviously but isn't putting out much of anything right now. Used to be a fave of mine and oft recommended.you might want t check out Vivian White/Valley her literotica page can be found here https://www.literotica.com/authors/RoleplayLiterate/works/stories
but if you want to support her patreon its here https://www.patreon.com/cw/VivianWhite Cuckold consequences is one of her best and i bought it after reading it on literotica to support her. The couple are not forced into cuckolding but the story is all about the husbands redemption arc
One aurthor i recommend to anyone is Tinto Selvaggio, nobody write better characters than tinto, i am surprised that his work is discussed rarely on this forum. I am looking for chapter 25-70 of his patreon series ālanie comes of ageā which is extension of his best works ābreaking us bothā and ābreaking us twiceā. I recommend it to anyone into hard cuckold erotica or anyone into hotwife erotica with world building.
There's a whole thread with lots of his stuff from Amazon and a bit from his Patreon at:
- Smiler111
- bdsm bull netorare
- Replies: 84
- Forum: Erotic Literature
But yeah, hard cuck including bi-stuff isn't everybody's cup of tea though its very popular. From the feelings expressed by some on this thread it might not be popular here.
What you said kind of make sense, yes. I felt the same when i first read breaking us both and when i was going through breaking us twice i thought this book will surely have at least a bittersweet ending looking at what vaughn has gone though over the two book but alas it wasnāt the case.This story is one of the worst I've ever read. I had to force myself to finish both books. Saying that Tinto is a master at writing characters is a complete jokeāthe clichĆ©s are on a level I've never seen before, and the character development is utterly unrealistic.
You can't even call this hard cuckold anymore; it's inhuman cuckoldry because the level of disrespect, cruelty, and humiliation is pushed to the absolute extreme.
Let's compare it to TA: Vaughn, the MC, makes Dan look like a newborn when it comes to being a wimpy cuckold. If you're looking for every humiliating kink imaginable to inflict on your main character, look no furtherāVaughn experiences all of them. By the end of the two books, he's barely even human anymore. What's even worse is that the author constantly shows us Vaughn's rebellious inner thoughts, only to have him contradict himself a second later.
Over the course of nearly 1,800 pages across both stories, he's betrayed, humiliated, and emotionally destroyed over and over again. Some scenes genuinely made me want to throw up (spoiler: he has "SISSY CUCK" written on his body while his wife, wearing their wedding dress, has "CUCK WHORE" written on hers, with the two of them being used side by side...).
Both wives start out as loving, very vanilla women, only to become cruel sluts who have absolutely no love or respect left for the MC. Of course, they both fall in love with the bull. One becomes completely submissive, while the other switches, but by the end neither of them has any real feelings left for the MC. The worst moments are when he tells them "I love you" and they either don't answer or respond with another humiliating remark.
And then there's the bull, Mr. Richmond. You thought Lester was a ridiculous character because of his almost omnipotent abilities, monstrous cock, and status as a sex god? Richmond makes Lester look ordinary. Lester doesn't have even 10% of Richmond's abilities or wealth. Richmond has every conceivable advantage: he's handsome, unbelievably rich, charismatic, much better endowed than the MC, possesses superhuman sexual prowess, and above all is a cruel sadist who enjoys destroying people purely for his own pleasure.
Finally, bisexuality is used solely as another tool to humiliate and break the MC, just like feminization and every other kink in the story. They're presented in the worst possible light, in an extremely negative way. At first glance, it might seem progressive or inclusive, but it's the exact opposite. The way these themes are introduced and used serves only to disgust the reader.
I had knots in my stomach and felt sick several times because of how inhumanly the MC is treated. The worst part is that he's been conditioned so thoroughly that, by the end, he's almost happy. There's still a tiny voice inside him questioning everything, but it's nearly been extinguished.
Yes, Tinto is a competent writer on a technical level, but his characters are so unrealistic and cartoonish that their development has neither logic nor depth. Simply humiliating and destroying the MC more and more isn't character development.

On Reddit someone mentioned "Training to Love It" - Kenny Wright / 3 parts. No toxic crazy cuck humiliation shit.
More emphasis on psyche than on sex. A kind of slow burn stories. The wife is slipping into depravity. It gets a llittle out of control. But in the end they bond stronger than before.
More of Kenny on Ocean of PDF https://oceanofpdf.com/category/authors/kenny-wright/
Spoilers
the clichƩ's : sad to read that, yes the other guy has a bigger dick and is more a fysical fit man, a BBC is added with even a bigger D. .She becomes total submissive when at his place. And he is not interested in the most sexy woman that like to get involved (so not realistic)...
But still, while reading I was interested in the development and started part 3 already.
View attachment 2860832 View attachment 2860834 View attachment 2860836
Most of the stories on here don't have happy endings. If there is it's usually an atl. ending.so now i have read chapter 8, took a couple of attempts due to angst i feel with Ray's manipulation and James weakness. I need to keep remembering James deserves what he gets somewhat.
So Jenna has definitely broken the rules 1. Ray was not allowed to come in her and 2. nothing should come between Jenna and James.
the first was self evident but the second is the gold chain she wore it to the ball with out telling husband. now the question is what James does about it. He could try giving the word and trying to end it all but with no reasoning i feel Jenna would not follow and go back to Ray ( this is my prediction for the next chapter).
If James wants to confront Jenna then he needs to lead with Ray Blackmailing him and then Ray manipulating Jenna. If he starts with the original scenario or Ray impersonating him then Jenna will be angry with James for his betrayal and lets face facts i don't think Jenna would be that upset anymore about the manipulation its led to her getting the sexual experience she has always craved even though she didn't know it.
The other thing to point out Jenna doesn't seem to realise the way she treats her husband regarding the condoms and the way she ties them off and puts them to the side is an element of humiliation and demeans him. he may get off on it , but she's cultivated that.
hard to imagine a happy ending for James in all this.
Real life? Hardly.Most of the stories on here don't have happy endings. If there is it's usually an atl. ending.
One thing that thing I find amusing is that most readers comment on how weak the husbands are. But I've always been amazed about is how the readers never say anything about is why would a woman marry or stay married to a guy like that. The reality is women don't marry guys like this and if the they do the husband has to put up with looking away a lot of the time. These are the guys you hear about goin over and finding their wife's at their boyfriends house crying for her to come home.
I used to think that these stories are mostly just crazy ass fantasy stories. But then I remembered that the whole world watched as this type of thing happened in real life. I happened on a reality show , is was for a while the most popular show on TV. I mean people watched it an American gold Medalist get cucked and then they turned him into a woman. The watched as he was kicked out of his family home while his wife moved on with a black dude that was 40yrs younger. All the while making millions of dollars, he'll two of them became billionaires.
I think you must have misunderstood what i meant. Is most women wouldn't marry a guy that would be a cuckold. I was ment that when people always read these stories they always say in real life a man wouldn't let that happen, I was saying that nobody bring up the fact that most women wouldn't be with these type of guys. Then about the other, It did happen on a TV show, it was Bruce Jenner. That show and what it brought to the Kardashians turn two of them into billionaires and the rest are all worth millions. So I don't know what your talking about not being "real life", but when sports illustrated gives you the woman of the year award the story tends to hold weight. The facts are there all the other is bullshit but you can see for yourselves how they are living now. The whole world watched their reality show and in the last couple seasons people watched and cheered the mom on as she started seeing and going out with other men out in public. She even brought in and went out with the guy she cheated on her first husband with. So some of these crazy stories you believe are to outlandish to be true one of the craziest happened on television.Real life? Hardly.
Men in these stories are often superficially "weak" in ways that don't really mesh with actual survival instincts. The stories essentially jump from 0 to 60 with "If a man is willing to let his wife fuck someone else, then he's too clueless or spineless to do anything else". Too often, there's no middle ground. No hard boundaries followed by a confrontation followed by emotional triage. The only sliding scale is how oblivious the husband is versus how powerless he is, and most long form stories spend a lot of time making various forms of obliviousness turn into powerlessness (like Toxic Attraction). I also wouldn't call reality TV "Real Life".
Reality television is a highly produced, contractually negotiated, heavily edited piece of entertainment designed to maximize ratings. Comparing the motivations of billionaires operating within a highly managed media empire to the psychological realities of a standard marriage is a massive logical leap.
I'm not saying that truly, actual abused cucks don't exist. But they aren't anywhere close to as common as this genre actually portrays, because real life actually tends to have nuance.
No, I understood what you meant, and I stand by what I said about the lack of nuance.I think you must have misunderstood what i meant. Is most women wouldn't marry a guy that would be a cuckold. I was ment that when people always read these stories they always say in real life a man wouldn't let that happen, I was saying that nobody bring up the fact that most women wouldn't be with these type of guys. Then about the other, It did happen on a TV show, it was Bruce Jenner. That show and what it brought to the Kardashians turn two of them into billionaires and the rest are all worth millions. So I don't know what your talking about not being "real life", but when sports illustrated gives you the woman of the year award the story tends to hold weight. The facts are there all the other is bullshit but you can see for yourselves how they are living now. The whole world watched their reality show and in the last couple seasons people watched and cheered the mom on as she started seeing and going out with other men out in public. She even brought in and went out with the guy she cheated on her first husband with. So some of these crazy stories you believe are to outlandish to be true one of the craziest happened on television.